...

We’re flavouring and scenting everything. But what happens when we do the same thing with leadership?

Walk around any supermarket and you’ll see it everywhere. Water with added flavour. Cleaning products infused with fragrances and smelling “fresher”. Laundry products promising exotic scents of pine forests or the ocean. Products that naturally have little or no smell suddenly smell of lavender, citrus, flowers or something supposedly “fresh”. We seem to have become obsessed with making everything smell or taste better than it naturally does.

Is there a leadership lesson here? Sometimes, trying to make something appear better than it really is can leave a very bad taste in your mouth.

Leadership isn’t always going to taste good

Leadership comes with difficult moments. Poor performance. Conflict. Difficult conversations. Organisational change. Redundancies. Challenging behaviours. Tough decisions. None of these are particularly pleasant, but they are part of the job.

Effective leaders don’t disguise them with a layer of positivity and hope they’ll go away. They face them. They communicate honestly. They take responsibility, and they recognise that authentic leadership doesn’t mean being positive all the time. It means being real.

Team gathered round a desk for an open, honest discussion

Your employees can smell artificial leadership a mile away

Leaders sometimes feel pressure to look like they have everything under control: the confident leader, the inspirational leader, the leader with all the answers. But when the image doesn’t match the reality, employees notice.

The gap between what a leader says and what they actually do is where trust starts to disappear. Once trust goes, rebuilding it is considerably harder than creating it in the first place. As we’ve written before, trust takes a lifetime to build and a moment to lose.

The same applies to employees

This isn’t just a leadership issue. Employees can also feel pressure to present a more polished or capable version of themselves: to appear more confident, more experienced, more resilient. However, if the reality doesn’t match the image, eventually they must deliver. That’s when the problems surface. Performance doesn’t meet expectations. Confidence takes a hit. Managers become frustrated. Colleagues lose trust and teamwork suffers. What started as an attempt to look good can ultimately put someone’s credibility, or even their job, at risk.

When you lie to others, you also have to live with the lie yourself, and that takes energy. In fact, it can be exhausting. Energy spent maintaining an image is energy that isn’t being spent on doing the job well.

What happens when nobody feels safe to be themselves?

This is where the issue becomes much bigger than individual authenticity. When people don’t feel able to be honest about mistakes, uncertainty, concerns or capability, they start protecting themselves, which is likely to create a damaging chain reaction:

Less trust → less openness → less collaboration → more control → more boundary protection → more blame.

Eventually, people stop asking “How can we improve or solve this together?” Instead, they start asking “How do I protect my back?”

That’s clearly not a performance culture. It’s a survival culture. In a survival culture it is difficult, if not impossible, to build a healthy, productive workplace, because people are spending their energy protecting themselves and their roles rather than contributing.

Colleagues joining hands as a sign of trust and teamwork

HR and business leaders: look beyond the policies

This is why workplace culture cannot be created simply through values statements, wellbeing initiatives or policies sitting on an intranet. Culture is experienced through behaviour. It’s what happens when someone makes a mistake. It’s how challenge is received. It’s whether managers admit they don’t know something. It’s whether employees can say “I need help.” It’s whether difficult conversations actually take place, and it’s whether people believe that what leaders say is what leaders genuinely mean. (It’s a question we also asked in Are your company values laminated or lived?)

You cannot manufacture trust. You cannot fragrance a toxic culture and expect it to become healthy, and you cannot keep adding layers of positivity to problems that need addressing.

Sometimes, natural is better

Perhaps that’s the real lesson from the supermarket shelf. Flavouring and scenting something may make it more appealing, but only temporarily. Eventually, the artificial layer becomes difficult to maintain.

Leadership is no different. You don’t need to make yourself smell like roses. You need to be authentic enough to acknowledge when something doesn’t smell right, deal with it and learn from it, while creating an environment where others feel able to do the same.

Authentic leadership builds trust. Trust strengthens teamwork. Teamwork supports performance. And people who don’t have to pretend can spend more of their energy doing what they were employed to do, and be happy doing it.

Before adding another layer of “flavour” to your workplace culture, ask yourself: are we making things genuinely better, or simply making them look, smell and sound better than they really are?

Sometimes, natural really is better. Even in leadership. And perhaps even in your gut microbiome.

How Green Key can help

Green Key helps leaders build the honesty, self-awareness and communication skills that create trust, through practical leadership skills training and one-to-one leadership coaching. We work with organisations across Oxfordshire, the Thames Valley and London, and online across the UK. Book an exploratory call to talk about your leadership team.

Frequently asked questions

What is authentic leadership?

Authentic leadership means being real rather than presenting a polished image. Authentic leaders face difficult moments such as poor performance, conflict and tough decisions honestly, take responsibility, and make sure what they do matches what they say.

Why does artificial leadership damage trust?

Employees notice when a leader’s words don’t match their actions, for example talking about openness while shutting down challenge, or promoting wellbeing while creating unsustainable workloads. That gap is where trust starts to disappear, and once it goes it is much harder to rebuild than it was to create.

What is a survival culture at work?

A survival culture is one where people don’t feel safe to be honest about mistakes, uncertainty or concerns, so they focus on protecting themselves instead of solving problems together. Less trust leads to less openness and collaboration, more control and more blame, which makes a healthy, productive workplace very hard to build.

×